Birmingham City Council has been forced to fine itself £472,000 after its own fleet repeatedly violated the city's Clean Air Zone regulations.
Since the emissions scheme launched in the city centre in 2021, council-owned vehicles have racked up 3,262 separate daily charges and fines totalling £472,253.
The waste department accounted for the majority of these breaches, despite the city experiencing a bin strike lasting 12 months.
The authority acknowledged it had spent the past year replacing vehicles that failed to meet emission standards. However, officials admitted that approximately one in eight council vehicles still do not comply with the zone's requirements.
The CAZ operates around the clock within Birmingham's ring road, using Automatic Number Plate Recognition to enforce compliance.
Government commissioners have been overseeing the council's finances since it declared effective bankruptcy through a Section 114 notice in 2023.
The council's charges and fines are roughly 20 times the amount paid by any other UK council operating a Clean Air Zone, Low Emission Zone, or Ultra Low Emission Zone that disclosed similar payments for breaching its own emission rules.
The daily charge for non-compliant cars, vans and taxis is currently £8, while HGVs and coaches face a £50 fee. Drivers who fail to pay within six days of entering the zone receive a £120 penalty, reduced to £60 if settled within a fortnight.
The council has fined itself nearly £500,000 due to breaching CAZ rules
| GETTYRevenue from these charges and fines contributes to CAZ operational costs and certain Government charges.
Any surplus must be directed towards transport or environmental initiatives and cannot be returned to the council's general budget.
Sharon Power, coordinator at Kings Heath Food Bank, condemned the council's expenditure as "absolutely appalling" given the current economic climate.
"The country's in this state, people are having to choose to heat or eat, and they're spending money right, left and centre," she told the BBC.
LATEST DEVELOPMENTS
Drivers must pay an £8 daily fee to enter the CAZ zone or risk being fined
| GETTYThe charity relies entirely on volunteer goodwill, but organisers reported that some drivers could no longer afford the zone's daily charges.
This shortage of volunteer drivers has had a significant impact on operations. The food bank now assists half the number of people it supported weekly before the emissions scheme began in 2021.
When the charity requested an exemption from CAZ requirements for its volunteers, the council turned down the application, according to organisers.
One volunteer driver received unexpected fines amounting to approximately £800 for his food bank journeys. He was required to obtain manufacturer documentation proving it met emission standards, prompting the fines to be cancelled.
The council introduced the CAZ in 2021
| PAThe authority operates certain exemption schemes based on specific criteria, but none exist specifically for council vehicles or those used by contractors.
The council stated it had created a central Vehicle Management Service designed to accelerate the shift towards a modernised, low emission fleet focused on efficiency, economy, safety and sustainability.
As of March 31, 142 vehicles from the council's 1,170-strong fleet remained non-compliant, representing 12 per cent of the total.
A council spokesperson explained that it had now established a central Vehicle Management Service to help "to fast-track transition to a modernised, low emission fleet, driving efficiency, economy, safety and sustainability".