BBC The Traitors fans fume they were 'robbed' by unaired scene following latest murder: 'Can't make it up!'

Olivia Gantzer

By Olivia Gantzer


Published: 23/01/2026

- 11:38

Viewers were expecting to see a big reveal on the show's spin-off episode

The Traitors star Roxy Wilson has opened up about her experience on the BBC show after narrowly missing out on the final, but eager fans have complained they were "robbed" to have missed out on a particular scene with the recruiter.

Ms Wilson was "murdered" by Traitors Rachel Duffy and Stephen Libby on Thursday, and viewers were then expecting to see the Faithful's response to finding out who the Traitors had been.


Ms Wilson had been firmly under the impression that James Baker was the villain of the game, and shared after her "murder" that she hoped Ms Duffy and Mr Libby would go all the way, believing them to be clear Faithfuls.

However, fans were left fuming on Thursday night during the show's spin-off programme, Uncloaked, which usually sees the moment the latest Faithful to leave discovers their co-stars' true identities.

Roxy

BBC The Traitors: Fans wanted to see the moment Roxy found out who the Traitors had been

|

BBC

However, due to the nature of the cliffhanger ending from Thursday's The Traitors, her response to finding out the truth wasn't shown to viewers.

Following two tie results during the Round Table, the fate of both Ms Duffy and Mr Baker hung in the balance.

Both had received the same amount of votes to be banished from fellow players, so host Claudia Winkleman was forced to step in and bring out the Chests of Chance to determine who would remain in the show.

Just before the outcome was revealed, though, the credits rolled, and fans have been forced to wait another night to find out whether the Faithful or Traitor would be making an exit.

Normally, the latest elimination features in Uncloaked to discuss their experience and find out who had been fooling them all along. However, the scene was missing from Thursday's show.

Taking to X, many were left furious not to see the big reveal, particularly as Ms Wilson had been so adamant yet wrong in her theories, deeming the pair of Traitors the most "honest" people in the game.

One fan shared: "I can't WAIT to see Roxy’s reaction on Uncloaked when she learns who the Traitors are. Truly one of the worst players ever, bless her."

A second complained: "Uncloaked you better get the footage of Roxy finding out Rachel and Stephen are traitors on my screen RIGHT NOW. I've already been robbed of seeing her face in the final!"

Roxy

BBC The Traitors: Roxy was certain Rachel and Stephen had been Faithfuls

|

BBC

Someone else quipped: "Can’t wait to see Roxy realise how honest Stephen and Rachel really are in uncloaked #TheTraitorsUK #TheTraitors."

"Why didn't we see Roxy get the scroll with the Stephen and Rachel reveal on Uncloaked? I can only assume they're keeping that till the final. Otherwise, we can assume it's because they didn't want to embarrass her. Lol #TheTraitors #TheTraitorsUK," echoed one more.

Others had concerns about the reason the moment wasn't shown, with one theorising: "Roxy looked so upset tonight on Uncloaked. Not showing her reaction to finding out it was Stephen & Rachel makes me think she had a bit of a breakdown.

"I hope not... As much as I love #TheTraitors it feels like a show that probably harms some contestants in cruel ways long term." (sic)

Rachel and Stephen

BBC The Traitors: Rachel and Stephen have been Traitors from the start

|

BBC

Another fan joked: "I have a strong feeling that the reason why UNCLOAKED didn’t show Roxy’s reaction to finding out who the traitors were is because she torched the whole room #TheTraitors #TraitorsUK."

One more argued: "James get a lot of c**p for never making sense when we've got Roxy who got every theory wrong, to then go on Uncloaked and hope that Steven and Rachel win as Faithfuls. Can't even make it up #TheTraitors." (sic)

The 32-year-old shared after her exit: "To be honest, I'm kind of happy, because it only gets so much harder.

"I think I've got as far as I could. I would have loved to have got to the final, but it was just always my aim to get as far as possible, so I’m really proud."