ITV Genius Game branded ‘Traitors knock-off' as ‘overcomplicated series’ leaves viewers irritated: ‘Hard work!’

WATCH HERE: Genius Game Trailer

ITV
Lauren Williams

By Lauren Williams


Published: 30/04/2025

- 22:13

Updated: 30/04/2025

- 22:19

The latest ITV gameshow sees David Tennant host 11 contestants in a bid to win big money

ITV Genius Game viewers were left switching off from the latest game show, which is hosted by David Tennant, with many claiming it’s “overcomplicated”.

The brand-new reality game show sees strategically minded players, chosen not just for their high intellectual prowess but also their social IQ, face the ultimate battle of survival.


To win, contestants have to participate in a host of never-before-seen games all designed to not only test their intellectual acumen but also encourage them to carefully and creatively use the art of manipulation to outfox their opponents and win a cash prize.

During the first episode, Tennant guided the eleven players, with exceptional abilities, through a series of mind-bending games.

The players needed to work together to be successful, but there could be only one winner.

In the first “Main Match”, the players faced Gold Heist, which challenged them to work together if they want to stay in the game.

The Genius Game

David Tennant hosts ITV's latest game show

ITV

If they won, they would have received a Token of Life and, alongside themselves, got the chance to choose a player to save.

But the losing player had to go head-to-head in the ultimate “Death Match”, choosing their opponent from the remaining players.

The loser was eliminated from the competition. With the stakes being high and with pressure on, it was a chance for the contestants to show if they would have been able to hold their nerve for the next round.

However, as excited viewers began to tune in and were looking forward to a new gameshow, many were left disappointed and switched off.

Genius Game

The 11 contestants all competing for a high prize pot

ITV

Taking to X, one penned: “#GeniusGame you need to be a genius to watch it. It's like @ITV producers thought 'How can we compete with #bbctraitors'.

Brain is completely fried. Totally overcomplicated! Don't think I will continue to watch.”

Someone else said: “I feel like I should watch #GeniusGame just in order to prove that it can't be that difficult to understand.

“But then it's an ITV reality show and I'm not a gormless, braindead f***wit so I just won't.”

A third raged: “I thought us thick people could just enjoy watching the nerds I never realised we had to BE a genius to enjoy the show.”

Another wrote: “How can anybody enjoy this programme if nobody understands how it works? The instructions are completely confusing with no recap whatsoever!

The Traitors

Viewers claimed the new show was trying too hard to be like The Traitors

BBC

“It’s like a cheap knock-off of The Traitors! Another poor programme from ITV!

I know I’ve had a few beers but what the actual fuck? If you have to be a genius to even watch it, let alone take part?!?!” a fifth expressed.

A sixth agreed: “I'm there for reality TV evolving and all that, but not at the expense of compromising entertainment value for overly complicated rules. This feels like hard work.” (sic)