State pension 'nightmare' as Tony Blair slammed over triple lock axe proposal

Patrick O'Donnell
Sat, 02 May 2026 14:41:08 +0000

Former Prime Minister Tony Blair's think tank is under fire over their "nightmare" policy proposal to scrap the state pension triple lock in favour of an alternative payment uprate mechanism.

The Tony Blair Institute (TBI) as called for the abolition of the state pension triple lock, proposing a radical "lifespan fund" to replace the current system.

TBI published a report yesterday arguing that Britain's pension framework is "outdated, increasingly unaffordable, and too rigid for the way people live and work".

Under the triple lock mechanism, introduced by the coalition government in 2010, pensions rise annually by the highest of earnings growth, inflation, or 2.5 per cent; this April saw a 4.8 per cent increase.

The think tank warned that pension expenditure will climb from approximately 5 per cent of GDP currently to 7.8 per cent by 2070, as pensioner numbers grow from 12.6 million to nearly 19 million.

Steve Webb, a partner at pensions consultancy LCP, has sharply criticised the proposals, describing the concept of tying state pension payments to individual health records and life expectancy as "deeply troubling".

Mr Webb raised concerns about confidentiality and data quality, noting the difficulty of accurately predicting life expectancy from medical records.

He pointed out that while the report claims it would not reward those with poor health due to lifestyle choices such as smoking, separating such factors from overall health would prove extremely challenging.

LATEST DEVELOPMENTS

State pension 'shock' as ONE MILLION retirees 'dragged into tax system' under HMRC rule

State pension triple lock could be scrapped under 'dystopian' Tony Blair proposal

Britons could access their state pension early under Tony Blair Institute's triple lock overhaul

The pensions expert warned that any appeals process for disputed pension rates could become "an administrative nightmare", calling the entire scheme "fiendishly complex and highly intrusive".

Age UK has mounted a defence of the triple lock, with charity director Caroline Abrahams arguing it should remain in place beyond the current parliament.

Ms Abrahams highlighted that the mechanism has improved living standards for some of the poorest pensioners, stating: "We continue to hear from older people who are struggling financially, and the extra money the triple lock delivers makes a meaningful difference to many lives."

She cited recent polling showing three in ten pensioners report financial difficulties, even before anticipated energy price rises.

The charity director called for a national conversation about the state pension's purpose, arguing current levels fail to provide a decent standard of living for those who depend on it.

A Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) spokesperson reaffirmed the Government's commitment to maintaining the triple lock for the remainder of this parliament, noting that millions of pensioners will see annual state pension increases of up to £2,100.